Central histamine (dys)function, antidepressants, appetite, autism and behavior

One day last week Monty, aged 12 with ASD, was watching an old Tom and Jerry DVD.  These DVDs, along with the other action-packed ones, once got hidden away because they drove Monty wild; now they do not.

This is what I was doing while Tom was chasing                                                                         Jerry.

I received another interesting comment from a reader who found a small dose of an antidepressant had a very positive effect on his 9 year old daughter:-

“My daughter (9, ASD) recently started on a very small dose of Remeron, in an effort to increase weight and as a bonus, hopefully improve sleep. It has done both. It also had an immediate unexpected but delightful side effect of improved social skills, more fluent speech and increased amount of conversation. The first day she tried it she made friends with random children in the park, and they had a discussion about how they would design their dream playground. (DD said she would invent and upside down slide, where you start at the bottom and slide up.) It has been amazing for her (so far.)  ”

In most families it is the parents who take the antidepressants.

I recalled that one class of antidepressant was actually developed from an old antihistamine drug, tricyclic antidepressants.

Remeron, otherwise known as Mirtazapine, is indeed a tricyclic antidepressant.

Not only is Remeron, in effect, a first generation antihistamine, i.e. one that was not designed to stay outside the blood brain barrier, but it is a rather potent one.

Within the brain Remeron/Mirtazapine:-

H₁R occupancy (H₁RO) of mirtazapine reached 80-90 % in the cerebral neocortex

Histamine H₁ receptor occupancy by the new-generation antidepressants fluvoxamine and mirtazapine: a positron emission tomography study in healthy volunteers.

This means that 80-90% of the type 1 histamine receptors in that part of the brain are blocked from action.

Histamine Receptors and the Blood Brain Barrier

There were several earlier posts in this blog regarding histamine.

There are four known types of histamine receptors H1, H2, H3 and H4.

In one way or the other, all four are likely relevant to autism.  Drugs are not yet available for H4.  H3 therapies are likely to improve cognitive function in some. H4 appears to play a role in the overexpression of mast cells in allergic tissues.  So those with severe mast cell issues should watch the H4 drug pipeline.

Histamine H4 Receptor Mediates Chemotaxis and Calcium Mobilization of Mast Cells

An important point to remember is that while histamine does not cross the Blood Brain Barrier (BBB), H1 antihistamines do cross, including the ones designed not to cross.

All antihistamines cross blood-brain barrier

Within the brain, histamine functions as a neurotransmitter, but it is not the same histamine as that released by mast cells in your nose, when you have hay fever.  Histamine is also produced inside the brain.

H3 receptors in the brain modulate the release of histamine.  Histamine release in the brain triggers secondary release of excitatory neurotransmitters such as glutamate and acetylcholine via stimulation of H₁ receptors in the cerebral cortex. Consequently, unlike the H₁ antagonist antihistamines which are sedating, H₃ antagonists have stimulant and nootropic effects, and are being researched as potential drugs for the treatment of neurodegenerative conditions such as Alzheimer's disease and also for ADHD.

H1 agonists should increase appetite and H3 agonists should reduce appetite.  So one day do not be surprised to read about wonder H3 slimming pills.

Outside the brain (CNS) all four types of receptor are found and have specific functions.

H1 receptors modulate circadian rhythm (sleep) as well as all those allergy and asthma symptoms.

H2 receptors modulate sinus rhythm (in your heart), stimulate  gastric acid secretion, inhibit antibody synthesis, T-cell proliferation and cytokine production.

So histamine dysfunction would contribute to many conditions that are known to be comorbid with autism:-

·        Obesity and also low appetite (both extremes)

·        Poor sleep

·        GERD/GORD/reflux

·        Cognitive impairment

·        Allergy

·        Mood disorders

As usual things are complicated, because the histamine receptors are slightly different in each part of the brain so your histamine antagonist/blocker “sticks” better on some than on others.  So one H1 antihistamine will be more sedating, or more appetite-increasing than another one.

H1 antihistamines in Autism

Most attention in this blog has been directed to the effect of H1 antihistamines outside the brain/CNS.  To a greater or lesser extent, all H1 antihistamines are also mast cell stabilizers.  They reduce the release of histamine itself, as well as blocking H1 receptors (and so relieving allergy symptoms).

Blocking the release of histamine outside the BBB stops the release of inflammatory cytokines like IL-6, which can, directly or indirectly, cross the blood brain barrier.

However many people report that common H1 antihistamines seem to improve autistic behavior, irrespective of any allergy being present. My assumption is that this may be the case with nine year old girl, certainly worth investigating.

Either there is a mild allergy that has gone unnoticed, or this must be the effect of blocking H1 receptors within the brain/CNS.

H3 antihistamines in Autism

I think it quite likely that some people with autism and schizophrenia would experience cognitive improvement from H3 antagonists.

It is perhaps odd that nobody has investigated the cognitive effects of Betahistine.

Betahistine has a very strong affinity as an antagonist for histamine  H₃ receptors and a weak affinity as an agonist for histamine H₁ receptors.

The disadvantage is that betahistine increases histamine levels outside the BBB, so not good for someone with asthma.

There is data on the effect of Betahistine on weight gain in schizophrenia:-

Reducing antipsychotic-induced weight gain in schizophrenia: a double-blind placebo-controlled study of reboxetine-betahistine combination.

It was safe, well tolerated and did reduce weight gain.  I would have liked to know the effect on cognitive function.

Conclusion

There may be too much histamine being released, or its degradation might be impaired (DAO, SAMe, & HMT are all implicated in autism/schizophrenia), or there may be over/under expression of histamine receptors in certain places.

For example in schizophrenia,  metabolites of histamine are increased in the cerebrospinal fluid of people, while the efficiency of H₁ receptor binding sites is decreased.

The role of the central histaminergic system on schizophrenia.

It would not be surprising if people with autism and histamine/mast cell related issues outside the brain, also have central (in the brain) histamine dysfunctions.

There are only 24,000 genes found in humans (there are 700+ autism genes).  As a result these genes have to be reused many times all over the body.  Any dysfunction may be reappear in surprising parts of the body.  Add to this the way the body is controlled by feedback loops and you can see a how very many things are inter-related.

This also explains why very clever ideas can work in vitro (in the lab) but completely fail when applied to humans. "Stumbled upon", which must really annoy some clever scientists, is a very valid discovery method and can still earn you top marks.

This also means that many potential therapies can have unintended side effects. Like the H3 antagonist Betahistine, which can cause gastric acid problems and itching.  Betahistine acting in the brain might be good for cognition, but might not be without drawbacks elsewhere in the body.

Coming back to Tom and Jerry and where this post started

As usual Jerry got the better of Tom.

Since continued used of Remeron might lead to obesity, it would be interesting to see if the autism benefits were maintained by using a more conventional H1 antihistamine.  The older ones should better cross the BBB, but will be more sedative.

The people currently using conventional H1 antihistamines to treat their n=1 case of autism, might want to compare the effect of the very small dose of Remeron.

The people using second generation conventional H1 antihistamines (Zyrtec, Claritin etc) to treat their n=1 case of autism might want to compare the effect of the old fashioned versions that, like Remeron, have high much higher H₁R occupancy in the brain.

For those still hungry (too much histamine) for more:-

 The histaminergic system in brain: neurophysiology

Histamine H3 receptor antagonists/inverse agonists on cognitive and motor processes: relevance to Alzheimer's disease, ADHD, schizophrenia, and drug abuse

The role of hypothalamic H1receptor antagonism in antipsychotic-induced weight gain.

  

Therapeutic potential of histamine H3 receptor agonist for thetreatment of obesity and diabetes mellitus

Summertime Raging in Autism – H1 Anti-histamine Effect on Histamine Levels and IL-6

Last summer, I wrote a lot about autism getting much worse in that time of the year and how I found that common “24 hour” anti-histamine drugs seemed to have a magical effect; but one that lasted only 2-3 hours. There were only visible signs of a mild allergy, which could indeed easily be overlooked.

I did later receive a message from a reader who noticed his child’s ASD behaviours were greatly improved by Zrtec and his doctor agreed to prescribe this H1 antihistamine all year round.

Recently, I stumbled upon a blog, rich with many comments of parents of kids with severer types of autism.  Here I noted some parents referring to “summertime raging”, and I thought to myself, I know what they mean.  Fortunately, I found out how to make it go away.

Ant-histamine drugs

The two most common antihistamine drugs are Claritin (Loratadine), its active derivative Aerius (Desloratadine) and Zrtec (Ceterizine) and its active derivative Xyzal (levocetirizine).

The main action of an antihistamine is not actually to reduce the amount of histamine in your blood, rather it is to block the effect of histamine on the H1 receptors.

An H2 antihistamine blocks H2 receptors that are mainly in your intestines, and is used to reduce the amount of acid in the stomach.

This led me on a quest for substances that actually stop the increase in histamine, rather than just blocking some effects.  The only thing that does this is something that can stop so-called mast cells from degranulating and spilling their load of histamine, serotonin, nerve growth factor and cytokines, including IL-6, into the blood; from where, all except serotonin, are free to travel to the brain, across the blood brain barrier (BBB).  Serotonin cannot cross the BBB.

According to the mast cell specialist Theoharides, conventional drugs are not genuine mast cell stabilizers.  There are some partial ones, like Ketotifen, Cromalin, Rupatadine and Azelastine, but Theoharides thinks naturally occurring flavonoids like Luteolin and Quercetin work best.

Last summer in this blog I looked at newly discovered histamine receptors types H3 and H4 which are known to be present in the brain.

So how is it that Claritin and Zrtec can reduce autistic behaviours ?

I did note that both the above drugs did reduce summertime raging and also the Theoharides' research that showed they probably should not, since they are not mast cell stabilizers. 

Since my blog reader also found Zrtec helpful, so much so he gives it to his kid year round and it now seems summertime raging is not an unusual phenomenon in autism, I did some more checking.

In spite of what Theoharides tells us, it turns out that both Claritin and Zrtec do indeed reduce the amount of histamine in the blood.

Also, it turns out that not only is the pro-inflammatory cytokine IL-6 released from mast cells but it is also released from another type of cell, called the endothelial cell.

The endothelium is the thin layer of cells that lines the interior surface of blood vessels and lymphatic vessels, forming an interface between circulating blood or lymph in the lumen and the rest of the vessel wall. The cells that form the endothelium are called endothelial cells. Endothelial cells in direct contact with blood are called vascular endothelial cells, whereas those in direct contact with lymph are known as lymphatic endothelial cells.

And what prompts endothelial cells to release IL-6? Histamine does.

Indeed we have studies showing how Claritin (loratadine) and  Zrtec (Ceterizine) reduce histamine and IL-6; it is the IL-6 from the endothelial cells.

Inhibitory activity of loratadine and descarboxyethoxyloratadine on histamine-induced activation of endothelial cells.

"CONCLUSION:

These results demonstrate that both L and DCL are active to reduce the histamine-induced activation of EC. Interestingly, DCL seems to be effective at lesser concentrations especially to inhibit cytokine secretion."

The above study would suggest that Aerius (DCL) should be more effective than Claritin (L) its predecessor.

Human Mast Cells(HMC-1 5C6) Enhance Interleukin-6 Production by Quiescent and Lipopolysaccharide-Stimulated Human Coronary Artery Endothelial Cells

"Histamine is a major constituent of the mast cell. The effect of histamine on endothelial cells is primarily mediated through H1R

Collectively, our results suggest that mast cell-derived histamine and proteases play an important role in vascular inflammation and calcification in addition to their well-recognized participation in allergic diseases."

This study, and others like it, show how mast cell degranulation contributes to heart disease.  This would suggest that mast cell stabilizers have a much wider role in human health than is realized.  Another example of how a red apple a day (with the skin) may indeed help keep the doctor away and a glass of red wine will do the same.  Both are rich sources of the mast stabilizer Quercetin.  The alcohol increases the bio-availability.

Cetirizinea histamine H1 receptor antagonist improves viral myocarditis

"Conclusion

These results suggest that cetirizine exerts its beneficial effects on viral myocarditis by suppressing expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines, genes related to cardiac remodeling in the hearts of mice."

So how do Claritin and Zrtec reduce summertime/year round raging in autism?  Well it could be histamine or it could be IL-6, we cannot know for sure.  The science tells us that the brain has many H3 and H4 receptors, so they are possibly to be implicated.  Or, it may just be IL-6;  histamine’s involvement could be just provoking the endothelial cells to release more IL-6.

Conclusion

Claritin/Zrtec/Xyzal are relatively cheap, in theory they are long lasting drugs.  In Monty, aged 10 with ASD, they all work for summertime time raging, but not for long.  Adults should take one per 24 hours.  Monty would need one every 3 hours.

The, supposedly better, mast cell stabilizers like Ketotifen and Rupatadine take a few days before they have any effect at all.  Azelastin is available as a nasal spray and is supposed to be effective quickly as an allergy treatment.

My preferred mast cell stabilizing, IL-6 inhibiting, strategy is to combine PEA (palmitoylethanolamide) which is already naturally in your body, with the flavonoid quercetin, which is found in the skin of red apples and red grapes.  In theory, according to the research, this is both a potent combination and should be free of harmful side effects.

Very frequent doses of Claritin/Zrtec/Xyzal are not going to be good.

Links

Blog with 1000s of parent comments, some are very insightful

  

Theoharides on mast cells

On this blog:-

http://epiphanyasd.blogspot.com/2014/02/is-subtype-of-autism-allergy-of-brain.html

http://epiphanyasd.blogspot.com/2014/03/palmitoylethanolamide-pea-vs-flavonoids.html

http://epiphanyasd.blogspot.com/2013/07/histamine-allergies-and-reducing.html

http://epiphanyasd.blogspot.com/2013/11/seasonal-autistic-mastocytosis.html

More on anti-histamines in Autism and introducing H4

In my previous posts on histamine, you would have read that I found that Claritin appeared to reduce autistic behaviours.  Once I had got to the bottom of what was going on, I found out that histamine has a long record of stimulating challenging behaviour in all children.  It also became clear that typical anti-histamines (H1 antagonists) are all slightly different and one may be effective in one person and ineffective in another.  Each one tends to have additional secondary effects.

It now appears that the secondary effect of certain H1 antagonists may actually be more important than the primary intended effect of reducing itchy eyes and runny noses.

There are three generations of H1 drugs.  The fastest working and most potent is still the first generation, the second generation are non-drowsy derivatives of the first generation.  The third generation are the active metabolite of the second generation.  As you will see in today’s central paper, the third generation probably does not warrant the tittle.  For many users they may be just expensive versions of the second generation drug.

The excellent paper  New anti histamines: a critical view is from Brazil, but it has an English version.  It is highly readable.  It tells of the specific secondary effects of certain second generation  H1 antagonists.   (She omits to mention the secondary effects of the first generation. Some people say Ketotifen is 1^st generation and other people say 2^nd generation, anyway it appears not to be sold in Brazil).  I suggest you read the paper, if you have a child with an ASD. The key section is this:

Antiallergic/anti-inflammatory effects

Originally, studies of the relative potencies of H1 antihistamines were based on the capacity of different compounds to competitively inhibit the H1 receptor binding of histamine, i.e. on their blocking effect on the receptor.⁸ Nevertheless, it has already been known for some time that, in addition to acting on H1 receptors, many H1 antihistamines, at appropriate doses, are capable of inhibiting not only the release of histamine by mast cells,^9,10 but also mast cell activation itself.¹¹ Some of them can even regulate the expression and/or release of cytokines, chemokines, adhesion molecules and inflammatory mediators.^5,8

Therefore, the antiallergic properties of H1 antihistamines are generally a reflection of their capacity to affect mast cell and basophil activity, inhibiting the release of preformed mediators such as histamine, tryptase, leukotrienes and others.⁸ Several second-generation H1 antihistamines have demonstrated antiallergic properties, irrespective of their interaction with the H1 receptor.^5,8

Chronic allergic inflammation resulting from the late-phase reaction, exhibits components that are similar to other forms of inflammation, including chemotaxis of inflammatory cells followed by activation and proliferation, with subsequent production and release of many chemical mediators. Among cells involved in allergic inflammation are: antigen-presenting cells (for example, macrophages), mast cells, basophils, T lymphocytes, epithelial/endothelial cells and eosinophils - major effectors of chronic inflammation. Cytokines, chemokines, inflammatory mediators and adhesion molecules also contribute to this process which ultimately leads to dysfunction of the affected organ.⁸

Many second-generation H1 antihistamines (particularly cetirizine) are capable of inhibiting the influx of eosinophils to the site of allergen challenge in sensitized individuals.^5,8 Studies have demonstrated that some of them can also alter adhesion molecules expression on epithelium and eosinophils, and reduce in vitro survival of eosinophils. Finally, some second-generation H1 antihistamines are capable, in vitro and in vivo, of altering the production of inflammatory cytokines (for example, TNF-a, IL-1b and IL-6) and the Th1/Th2 balance regulation cytokines (for example, IL-4 and IL-13).^5,8

Therefore, it is well established that, in addition to their effects on H1 receptors, many second-generation H1 antihistamines also manifest antiallergic and anti-inflammatory properties which differ depending upon their molecules and the experiments used for their evaluation.⁵

 

From my own experience, I have already replaced Claritine (Loratadine) with Cetirizine to see if it will remain active for longer.  Rather than working for 24 hours, Claritine is working for about 5 hours.

I thought Cetirizine might remain active for longer, but the main difference seems to be in how it works, rather than for how long it works.  With Cetirizine autistic behaviour has pretty much returned to where it was at the start of summer, before the allergy season.  With Claritine things improved greatly, but not all the way back to "normal".

Reading the paper and one of its references -

Compared pharmacological characteristics in humans of racemic cetirizine and levocetirizine, two histamine H1-receptorantagonists

makes me think that the expensive new  version of Cetirizine, called Levocetirizine, might be even better.  It happens to be available locally, but it is seven times as expensive.

The Brazilian paper does rather contradict some of what Dr Theoharides says about stabilizing mast cells.  You can choose who you think has got it right.  The good thing is that both Dr Inês Cristina Camelo-Nunes and Dr Theoharides seem very serious, objective people, which cannot be said about all the people offering their advice on the internet.

In fact, I found an interesting paper on the anti-inflammatory effects of the new version of Claritin, called Aerius/Clarinex (Desloratadine).

Antihistaminic, Anti-Inflammatory, and Antiallergic  Properties of the Nonsedating Second-Generation Antihistamine Desloratadine: A Review ofthe Evidence

It really seems to be the case of trying several antihistamines and selecting the one that works best for you.

 

The H4 Histamine Receptor and Inflammation

You may recall that there is a fourth histamine receptor, naturally called H4.

It was only recently discovered, as you might guess from the short entry in Wikipedia.  It seems that the H4 receptor plays a substantial role in the inflammatory response.  It is seen as playing a key role in conditions ranging from arthritis to asthma.

Here is a full text paper for those interested in the science:-

The role of histamine H4 receptor in immune and inflammatory disorders

 Here is a graphic from that paper:-

I wonder if that H4 is a ticking bomb in autism as well ?

Those more peaceful people among you will be less aware of what C4 is, and hence the sticks of H4 dynamite.