Preventing Miscarriages/Autism using Progesterone? And Sex-Specific Fetal and Placental Responses to Adversity

 

Today’s post returns to the theme of reducing the incidence/severity of future autism and introduces another factor that helps explain why girls have some degree of protection from autism.

The focus today is on female hormones and progesterone in particular.

It does look like hormones can play a role in both triggering and potentially treating some autism, but it is not an area likely to be followed up on in the mainstream.

We have seen previously in this blog that some infertility experts find an association between miscarriage and autism. One US fertility doctor has a prevent miscarriages website and a prevent autism website, because his feeling is that by reducing miscarriage risk, you may also reduce autism risk. He was shocked by how many of his fertility patients have other offspring with autism.

This should really be common sense.

·        In-utero stress increases the chance of a miscarriage

·        In-utero stress increases the chance of autism

The common solution would be to reduce sources of in-utero stress.  Which sounds simpler than it is.

I have previously looked in some detail into therapies that improve outcomes in traumatic brain injury (TBI), because much damage done in a TBI from a car crash, or skiing accident, occurs after the accident, as the brain over-reacts to the trauma and this then causes irreparable damage. Both the female hormones estradiol and progesterone, if given promptly, improve the outcome in TBI.  Another highly neuroprotective drug is Atorvastatin, from my son’s Polypill therapy, which has also been shown to improve outcomes in TBI; we even know how this happens. Atorvastatin, given intravenously, can extinguish a cytokine storm. Cytokine storms even play a key role in severe Covid-19, when lungs and other organs are damaged by the over-response of the immune system.

I was pleased to see that progesterone has recently been adopted as an approved therapy to prevent miscarriages in the United Kingdom.  I am actually really surprised that they were allowed to make the necessary clinical trials.  I would have thought this would be seen as unethical and risky.

 

Progesterone recommended to prevent early miscarriage

One of those behind the Tommy's National Centre for Miscarriage Research research, Prof Arri Coomarasamy, from the University of Birmingham, said  "This is a very significant moment.  We have an intervention that works that can stop a miscarriage. This gives hope to thousands of couples throughout UK. But it's really important to appreciate that only some miscarriages can be prevented by progesterone. There are other causes for miscarriages. We still need to study them. We need to find other effective treatment. About one in four pregnancies ends in miscarriage - the vast majority in the first few months or trimester.” 

 

Progesterone could prevent 8,450 miscarriages a year, finds new research 

PRISM studied 4,153 women with early pregnancy bleeding at 48 hospitals in the UK and found there was a 5% increase in the number of babies born to those who were given progesterone who had previously had one or more miscarriages, compared to those given a placebo.

The benefit was even greater for the women who had previous ‘recurrent miscarriages’ (i.e., three or more miscarriages) – with a 15% increase in the live birth rate in the progesterone group compared to the placebo group.

 

A 5% increase does not sound much.

A 5% reduction in autism incidence probably would not be seen as statistically significant. 5% would not be a very high hurdle for an autism prevention therapy. With a package of therapies, I think you could do very much better. I would consider “good” to be at least a one third reduction in genuine cases. Of course, it would be more complex, since in reality you would be reducing severity of autism. Autism is not binary, more like shades of grey.

 

Would progesterone reduce the risk of future autism?

I do not think we will ever get the answer that question.

Preventing miscarriage is seen as much more important than preventing autism.

The evidence for immediate treatment with progesterone or atorvastatin, after a head injury, has not led to its widespread adoption.  Try explaining that one to Mrs Schumacher (wife of the Formula One racing star, who had a traumatic brain injury while skiing)

The key take away from the PRISM miscarriage study is that progesterone treatment in pregnant women is safe.  It is also inexpensive.

 

Prenatal Hormones in Autism

In a perfect world, you would study hormone levels in pregnant women and find clear associations with autism incidence in offspring. We do not live in such a world.

In the research, hormone levels are all over the place and vary from study to study.

This can be seen as good news, since the range is so wide you can very likely increase the level of certain hormones without any unintended consequences.

  

Foetal oestrogens and autism

Oestradiol, oestrone, oestriol and progesterone each related to autism in univariate analyses after correction with false discovery rate. A comparison of standardised odds ratios showed that oestradiol, oestrone and progesterone had the largest effects on autism likelihood. These results for the first time show that prenatal oestrogens contribute to autism likelihood,

 

When I look at the above graph my conclusion is that the fetal estradiol (oestradiol, in UK English) level is all over the place.  It is nonsense to conclude that high levels are associated with autism. 

 

Autism Spectrum Disorder Risk in Relation to Maternal Mid-Pregnancy Serum Hormone and Protein Markers from Prenatal Screening in California

Results from this large, population-based study suggest that prenatal levels of the hormones, estriol and a gonadotropin (hCG), as well as MSAFP are associated with altered risks of having a child who later develops autism. Consistently, the risk of ASD was increased at lower levels of uE3; modelled both categorically or continuously, and examining the distribution graphically, the curve seems shifted to the left for cases. Further, the risk of ASD was increased with higher levels of MSAFP, while the associations with hCG were with both low and high levels. Although associations were modest, the fact that our results are based on levels of these prenatal markers measured during a developmentally-relevant period, and account for potential confounders, p

 

Our results suggest that continued investigation of prenatal hormones and possible mechanisms for an association with ASD is warranted. The associations we report were not of a large magnitude, which may make replication of the findings difficult in other studies that do not have access to the large numbers and unique resources we used. The 90th percentiles reflect MoMs of 1.7–2.0, which are not particularly high, but approach prenatal screening risk cut-points currently in use for other conditions (usually 2.0–2.5 MoM). The 10th percentile of uE3 is about 0.75 MoM. Measurement of additional estrogens, as well as androgens, from blood samples collected during pregnancy would be an interesting avenue for future research, if available in large enough studies. In addition, studies of endocrine-disrupting chemicals and genes involved in steroid hormone metabolism may yield further clues to a hormonal etiology for autism. Though modest increases in risk were seen in this large study, converging evidence suggests that ASD has multiple causes, and thus, identifying factors with small associated risks may help to better understand ASD and potential mechanistic pathways.

  

The Prenatal Hormone Milieu in Autism Spectrum Disorder

Though the etiology of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) remains largely unknown, recent findings suggest that hormone dysregulation within the prenatal environment, in conjunction with genetic factors, may alter fetal neurodevelopment. Early emphasis has been placed on the potential role of in utero exposure to androgens, particularly testosterone, to theorize ASD as the manifestation of an “extreme male brain.” The relationship between autism risk and obstetric conditions associated with inflammation and steroid dysregulation merits a much broader understanding of the in utero steroid environment and its potential influence on fetal neuroendocrine development. The exploration of hormone dysregulation in the prenatal environment and ASD development builds upon prior research publishing associations with obstetric conditions and ASD risk. The insight gained may be applied to the development of chronic adult metabolic diseases that share prenatal risk factors with ASD. Future research directions will also be discussed.

 

Female placentas are “superior” to male placentas.  Note the placenta has the same sex as the fetus and yes, it is a binary choice.

  

Sex-Specific Fetal and Placental Responses to Adversity

Fetal growth, development, and HPA axis programming in the setting of obstetric adversity differ by fetal sex (173–175). These sex-specific responses serve as additional mechanisms in which to consider male ASD predominance (see Figure 2). As the placenta is derived from extra-embryonic tissues, the placenta has the same sex as the fetus (178). Evidence suggests that the placentas of male and female fetuses differ in response to adverse prenatal environments through modulation of steroid pathways, placental genes, and protein synthesis (176). Placental growth and structure differ by sex, with male placentas being smaller in size but more efficient at nutrient and oxygen delivery (179, 180). Fetal growth depends upon the limited capacity of the maternal-placental interface to deliver oxygen and nutrients. Thus, greater placental efficiency among males precipitates faster somatic growth while increasing vulnerability to in utero perturbations (179, 181). This may have deleterious neurodevelopmental consequences, as fetal brain development relies on the availability of oxygen and nutrients such as fatty acids, glucose, and amino acids (131, 182, 183). In contrast, female placentas may have superior ability to buffer and adapt to suboptimal prenatal conditions (180).

 

Sex-specific fetal and placental adaptations to maternal adversity. Placentas of male and female fetuses respond differently to mild forms of maternal adversity. In the placenta of female fetuses, multiple changes in glucocorticoid barrier enzyme activity, gene expression, and protein synthesis occur leading to decreased growth (176, 177). This is advantageous as it preserves fetal oxygen and nutrient delivery. In the placenta of male fetuses, minimal changes in gene and protein expression occur, and the male fetus continues to grow incurring increased vulnerability to adverse outcomes (176). 

Figure 3 links heightened in utero stress from inflammation, stressors, and metabolic disturbances to perturbation within the prenatal hormone milieu. Through pCRH stimulation, the placenta upregulates fetal HPA axis activity in response to in utero stress. Subsequently, the fetal adrenal glands increase DHEA(S) synthesis leading to elevated placental estradiol production. Higher placental estradiol and pCRH production promotes HPA axis maturation denoted by fetal adrenal de novo cortisol synthesis. In response to in utero stress, the placental also increases hCG production which stimulates fetal gonadal testosterone synthesis.

 

Linking in utero stress to increased fetal steroidogenic activity and ASD biomarkers at mid-gestation.

 

In utero stress we see raises estradiol in the mother, but also increases testosterone in the males fetus.

The stress hormone, cortisol is elevated in the fetus.

You might imagine that less testosterone and more estradiol would be neuroprotective.

We know that progesterone is neuroprotective and now we know that its use is safe.

 

Conclusion 

Nature does sometimes stumble short of perfection and this is inevitable.  Going too far preventing miscarriages would not be wise, but improving the outlook of a viable fetus looks like a good idea.

Miscarriage is defined as pregnancy loss before 23 weeks’ gestation.

More than 80% of miscarriages occur before the 12th week, and the rate decreases rapidly thereafter.

Chromosomal anomalies cause at least half of these early miscarriages; for example, male fetuses with Rett Syndrome.  This is nature’s way of dealing with a non-viable fetus.  Only girls with Rett Syndrome can survive, since they have one good copy of the the MECP2 gene, males have none. MECP2 is on the X chromosome (girls have XX and boys have XY).

A little helping hand from Progesterone looks like a wise idea.

But, how slowly things move in medical science. The paper below is from 2013.

Use of progestagens during early pregnancy

“During the past 50 years several trials investigated the use of progestagens for the prevention of miscarriage. Actually the therapeutic value of progestagens remains to be established. This might be due to the poor design of the studies which evaluated hormone effectiveness”

 

The issue with using any hormone to prevent/minimize autism is the potential for harm.  This did not seem to worry people in 60 years of trials in miscarriage.

I think we can conclude that progesterone for the prevention/reduction in severity of autism is very likely entirely safe.  Would it be beneficial?

We know that women with Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), a condition in which the ovaries produce an abnormal amount of androgens (male hormones), have an increased chance of producing children with autism.  They might be a good place to start with a clinical trial.

The fact that female placentas give more protection against adversity during pregnancy is interesting and another contributing factor to the lower prevalence of autism in girls.  It is only certain types of autism where girls have protection. In the case of severe autism, girls are more likely to have detectable genetic anomalies than boys, making whole exome sequencing (WES) well worthwhile. It looks like girls are protected somewhat from multifactorial autism, which I think makes sense; they might just end up with some dyslexia or sub-clinical autism.

Multifactorial autism should be the type that you can minimize, by lightening the contributing adverse burdens.  This itself requires a multifactorial approach.

Learning from GABAa Dysfunction in Huntington’s Disease – useful ideas for Autism therapies?

Today’s post is really for the regular readers of this blog who are interested in the GABA switch and Bumetanide. It is not light reading.  We see how advanced some Taiwanese researchers are in their understanding of GABA_A dysfunctions in Huntington’s Disease.

Taipei 101, briefly the world’s tallest building

It is an excellent paper and much of it is applicable to autism. There are some omissions, but you will struggle to find a more complete paper.

They even go into the detail of altered the sub-unit expression of GABA_A receptors that occurs as the disease progresses. I think that correcting sub-unit miss-expression has great potential in treating some autism.

Huntington’s is an inherited brain disorder that first manifests itself around the age of 40 and then progresses for the next 15 to 20 years.

Much autism is present prior to birth but there is a progression that occurs as the brain develops in early childhood. Some people do seem to be entirely typical at birth and only around 2 years old develop symptoms. After 5 years old you cannot really develop “autism”, just the symptoms might not get noticed till later in life.

Schizophrenia only develops in early to mid-adulthood.

It is surprising to many people that such varied disorders share some similar aspects of biology.

In terms of practical interventions, in today’s paper these include:       

·        Inhibition of NKCC1 (bumetanide)

·        Activation of KCC2 (N-Ethylmaleimide)

·        Enhancer of CKB (creatine)

·        Inhibitor of WNK/SPAK

·        Activation of extra-synaptic GABAa receptors (taurine, progesterone)

·        Activation of synaptic GABAa receptors (zolpidem, alprazolam)

·        Inhibition of GABA transport mechanism (Tiagabine)

One thing to note is that activating GABAa receptors may well have a negative effect in some people.

Sub-unit specific therapies, like very low dose clonazepam targeting α3, are not mentioned in this paper, nor is the role of GABAb on NKCC1/KCC2 expression.

We are familiar with Bumetanide as an NKCC1 blocker intervention in autism, but looking at the list there are other common autism therapies (creatine and taurine) and the female hormone progesterone. We come upon the beneficial effect of female hormones on a regular basis in this blog (estradiol, pregnenalone, progesterone …).  We even saw how a sub-SSRI dose of Prozac increases the amount of the neurosteroid 3α-hydroxy-5α-pregnan-20-one (Allo) that potently, positively, and allosterically modulates GABA action at GABA_A receptors. Progesterone is converted to Allo in the body.

 

Here is the excellent paper on Huntington’s:-

Insights into GABAAergic system alteration in Huntington’s disease

                                                                                                               

An overview of the g-aminobutyric acid (GABA) signalling system. (a) GABA homeostasis is regulated by neurons and astrocytes. GABA is synthesized by GAD65/67 from glutamate in neurons, while astrocytic GABA is synthesized through MAOB. The release of GABA is mediated by membrane depolarization in neurons and Best1 in astrocytes. The reuptake of GABA is mediated through GAT1 in neurons and GAT3 in astrocytes. The metabolism of GABA is mediated by GABA-T in neurons and astrocytes. The reuptake of GABA in astrocytes is further transformed into glutamine via the TCA cycle and glutamine synthetase (GS). The glutamine is then transported to neurons and converted to glutamate for regeneration of GABA.

(b) GABAA receptors are heteropentameric complexes assembled from 19 different subunits. The compositions of different subunits determines the subcellular distributions and functional properties of the receptors. Phasic inhibition is mediated via the activation of synaptic GABAA receptors following brief exposure to a high concentration of extracellular GABA. Tonic inhibition is mediated via the activation of extrasynaptic GABAA receptors by a low concentration of ambient GABA.

c) The excitatory inhibitory response of GABA is driven by the chloride gradient across cell membranes, which can be determined via two cation–chloride cotransporters (NKCC1 and KCC2). The high expression of NKCC1 during the developmental stage maintains higher intracellular [Cl2] via chloride influx to the cell. The activation of GABAA receptors at an early developmental stage results in an outward flow of chloride and an excitatory GABAergic response. As neurons mature, the high expression of KCC2 maintains lower intracellular [Cl2] via chloride efflux out of the cell. The activation of GABAA receptors on mature neurons results in the inward flow of chloride and an inhibitory GABAergic response.

An excerpt showing data on sub-unit misexpression in different parts of the brain at different stages of the disease

5.2. Modulation of chloride homeostasis via cation – chloride cotransporters

Emerging evidence suggests that chloride homeostasis is a therapeutic target for HD. Pharmacological agents that target cation–chloride cotransporters (i.e. NKCC1 or KCC2) therefore might be used to treat HD (figure 3b). Of note, dysregulation of cation–chloride cotransporters and GABA polarity was associated with several neuropsychiatric disorders [70,134–139] (reviewed in [27,140]). Such abnormal excitatory GABAA receptor neurotransmission can be rescued by bumetanide, an NKCC1 inhibitor that decreases intracellular chloride concentration. Bumetanide is an FDA-approved diuretic agent that has been used in the clinic. It attenuates many neurological and psychiatric disorders in preclinical studies and some clinical trials for traumatic brain injury, seizure, chronic pain, cerebral infarction, Down syndrome, schizophrenia, fragile X syndrome and autism (reviewed in [141]). Daily intraperitoneal injections of bumetanide also restored the impaired motor function of HD mice. The effect of bumetanide is likely to be mediated by NKCC1 because genetic ablation of NKCC1 in the striatum also rescued the motor deficits in R6/2 mice. This study uncovered a previously unrecognized depolarizing or excitatory action of GABA in the aberrant motor control in HD. In addition, chronic treatment with bumetanide also improved the impaired memory in R6/2 mice [69], supporting the importance of NKCC1 in HD pathogenesis. Owing to the poor ability of bumetanide to pass through the blood–brain barrier, further optimization of bumetanide and other NKCC1 inhibitors is warranted [142,143]. Disruption of KCC2 function is detrimental to inhibitory transmission and agents to activate KCC2 function would be beneficial in HD. However, no agonist of KCC2 has been described until very recently [144,145]. A new KCC2 agonist (CLP290) has been shown to facilitate functional recovery after spinal cord injury [145]. It would be of great interest to evaluate the effect of KCC2 agonists on HD progression. Another KCC2 activator, CLP257, was found to increase the cell surface expression of KCC2 in a rat model of neuropathic pain [146]. Post-translational modification of KCC2 by kinases may modulate the function of KCC2. The WNK/ SPAK kinase complex, composed of WNK (with no lysine) and SPAK (SPS1-related proline/alanine-rich kinase), is known to phosphorylate and stimulate NKCC1 or inhibit KCC2 [147]. Thus, compounds that inhibit WNK/SPAK kinases will result in KCC2 activation and NKCC1 inhibition. Some compounds have been noted as potential inhibitors of WNK/SPAK kinases and need to be further tested for their effects on cation –chloride cotransporters [148–150]. An alternative mechanism to activate KCC2 is manipulation of its interacting proteins (e.g. CKB [65,66]). Because CKB could activate the function of KCC2 [65,66], CKB enhancers may increase the function of KCC2. In HD, reduced expression and activity of CKB is associated with motor deficits and hearing impairment [68,88]. Enhancing CKB activity by creatine supplements ameliorated the motor deficits and hearing impairment of HD mice. It is worthwhile to further investigate the interaction of KCC2 and CKB in GABAergic neurotransmission and motor deficits in HD. The depolarizing GABA action with altered expression levels of NKCC1 or KCC2 is associated with neuroinflammation in HD brains [32,69]. Blockade of TNF-a using Xpro1595 (a dominant negative inhibitor of soluble TNF-a) [151] in vivo led to significant beneficial effects on disease progression in HD mice [152] and reduced the expression of NKCC1. It would be of great interest to test the effect of other anti-inflammatory agents [153] on the function and expression of NKCC1 and GABAergic inhibition. Neuroinflammation is implicated in most neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer’s disease and Parkinson’s disease [154,155], and the interaction of cation–chloride cotransporters and neuroinflammation in GABAergic neurotransmission may also play a critical role in other neurodegenerative diseases.

Figure 2. Molecular mechanism(s) underlying the abnormal GABAAergic system in HD. (a) In the normal condition, adult neurons express high KCC2 and few NKCC1 to maintain the lower intracellular chloride concentration, which results in an inward flow of chloride when GABAA receptors are activated. Astrocytes function normally for the homeostasis of glutamate, potassium and glutamate/GABA-glutamine cycle. (b) In Huntington’s disease, reduced GABAA receptor-mediated neuronal inhibition is associated with enhanced NKCC1 expression and a decreased expression in KCC2 and membrane localized GABAA receptors. The dysregulated GABAAergic system might be caused by mutant HTT, excitotoxicity, neuroinflammation or other factors. Mutant HTT in neurons alters the transcription of genes (GABAAR and KCC2) through interactions with transcriptional activators (SP1) and repressors (REST/NRSF). Mutant HTT in neurons also disrupts the intracellular trafficking of GABAARs to the cellular membrane. HD astrocytes have impaired homeostasis of extracellular potassium/glutamate (due to deficits of astrocytic Kir4.1 channel and glutamate transporters, Glt-1) and cause neuronal excitability, which might be related to the changes of KCC2, NKCC1 and GABAAR. The activity of KCC2 could be affected through its interacting proteins, such as CKB and mHTT. Neuroinflammation, which is evoked by the interaction of HD astrocyte and microglia, enhances NKCC1 expression in neurons at the transcriptional level through an NF-kB-dependent pathway. HD astrocytes also have compromised astrocytic metabolism of glutamate/GABA–glutamine cycle that contributes to lower GABA synthesis.

Notably, neuroinflammation and the GABA neurotransmitter system are reciprocally regulated in the brain (reviewed in [104,105]). Specifically, neuroinflammation induces changes in the GABA neurotransmitter system, such as reduced GABAA receptor subunit expression, while activation

of GABAA receptors likely antagonizes inflammation.

TNF-a, a proinflammatory cytokine, induces a downregulation of the surface expression of GABAARs containing a1, a2, b2/3 and g2 subunits and a decrease in inhibitory synaptic strength in a cellular model of hippocampal neuron culture [106]. The same group further demonstrated that protein phosphatase 1-dependent trafficking of GABAARs was involved in the TNF-a evoked downregulation of GABAergic neurotransmission [107]. Upregulation of TNF-a also negatively impacts the expression of GABAAR a2 subunit mRNA and thus decreases the presynaptic inhibition in the dorsal root ganglion in a rat experimental neuropathic painmodel [108]. Conversely, blockade of central GABAARs in mice by aGABAAR antagonist increased both the basal and restraint stress-induced plasma IL-6 levels [109]. Inhibition of GABAAR activation by picrotoxin increased the nuclear translocation of NF-kB in acute hippocampal slice preparations [110]. Collectively, neuroinflammation

weakens the inhibitory synaptic strength in neurons, at least partly, through the reduction of GABAARs.

The reduced expression and function of GABAARs may further increase inflammatory responses. It remains elusive whether the same mechanism occurs in the inflammatory environment in HD brains.

hyperexcitability resulting from deficiency of astrocytic Kir4.1 might have also contributed to neuronal NKCC1 upregulation and altered GABAergic signalling in HD brains.

Figure 3. Strategy to target (a) GABAAR and (b) cation–chloride cotransporters as potential therapeutic avenues. (a) The GABAergic system is influenced directly by agents that (1) target synaptic GABAAR, (2) increase tonic GABA current or interfere with synaptic GABA concentrations via a reduction of GABA reuptake (3), and (4) block GABA metabolism.

5.1. Modulating the GABAA receptor as a therapeutic target

In view of the presently discovered HD-related deficit in the GABA system, the question arises whether HD patients can benefit from drugs that stimulate the GABA system (figure 3a). HD patients suffer from motor abnormalities and

non-motor symptoms, including cognitive deficits, psychiatric symptoms, sleep disturbance, irritability, anxiety, depression and an increased incidence of seizures [74,77,116,117].

Seizures are a well-established part of juvenile HD but no more prevalent in adult-onset HD than in the general population [73,74,118]. Several pharmacological compounds can enhance inhibitory GABAergic neurotransmission by targeting GABAAR and thereby producing sedative, anxiolytic, anticonvulsant and muscle-relaxant effects. A recent study demonstrated that zolpidem, a GABAAR modulator that enhances GABA inhibition mainly via the a1-containing GABAA receptors, corrected sleep disturbance and electroencephalographic abnormalities in symptomatic HD mice (R6/2) [119]. Alprazolam, a benzodiazepine-activating GABA receptor, reversed the dysregulated circadian rhythms and improved cognitive performance of HD mice (R6/2) [120].

In addition, progesterone, a positive modulator of GABAAR, significantly reversed the behavioural impairment in a 3-nitropropionic acid (3-NP)-induced HD rat model [121]. Apart from modulating the activity of the GABAergic system by interfering directly with the receptor, pharmacological agents can also interfere with synaptic GABA concentrations. Tiagabine, a drug that specifically blocks the GABA transporter (GAT1) to increase synaptic GABA level,was found to improve motor performance and extend survival inN171-82Q and R6/2 mice [122]. It is also worth evaluating whether vigabatrin, a GABA-T inhibitor that blocksGABAcatabolismin neurons and astrocytes [123], plays a role in the compromised astrocytic glutamate–GABA–glutamine cycling [56]. Interestingly, taurine exerted GABAA agonistic and antioxidant activities in a 3-NP HD model and improved locomotor deficits and increased GABA levels [124]. However, several early studies failed to provide the expected benefits of GABA analogues in slowing disease progression in HD patients [125–127]. For example, gaboxadol, an agonist for the extrasynaptic d-containing GABAA receptor, failed to improve the decline in cognitive and motor functions of five HD patients during a short two-week trial, but it caused side effects at the maximal dose [125]. Interestingly, although treatment with muscimol (a potent agonist of GABA receptors) did not improve motor or cognitive deficits in 10HDpatients, it did ameliorate chorea in the most severely hyperkinetic patient [126]. The therapeutic failure of GABA stimulation in early clinical trials does not argue against the importance of GABAergic deficits in HD pathogenesis. The alteration of GABAergic circuits plays a primary role or is a compensatory response to excitotoxicity, and it may contribute to HD by disrupting the balance between the excitation and inhibition systems and the overall functions of neuronal circuits. Because the subunits of the GABAA receptor are brain region- or neuron subtypespecific, the choice of drugs may have distinct effects on the brain region or neuronal population targeted [128–130]. For example, the expression of GABAAR subunits is differentially altered in MSNs and other striatal interneurons in HD 54,60]. The early involvement of D2-expressing MSNs can cause chorea [131], while dysfunctional PV-expressing interneurons can cause dystonia in HD patients [132]. Specific alteration in neuronal populations and receptor subtypes during HD progression needs to be taken into consideration when treating the dysfunction of GABAergic circuitry.

Notably, striatal tonic inhibition mediated by the dcontaining GABAARs may have neuroprotective effects against excitotoxicity in the adult striatum [63]. Because the reductions in d-containing GABAARs and tonic GABA currents in D2-expressing MSNs have been observed in early HD [32,39,40,54,61], it would be of great interest to evaluate the effects of several available compounds, such as alphaxalone and ganaxolone [133], that target d-containing GABAARs, in animal models of HD.

(b) GABAAR-mediated signalling in HD neurons is depolarizing due to the high intracellular chloride concentration caused by high NKCC1 expression and low KCC2 expression. Rescuing the function of cation–chloride cotransporters can occur via (1) inhibition of NKCC1 activity using bumetanide, (2, 3) increase in KCC2 function using a KCC2 activator or CKB enhancer, and (4) inhibitors of WNK/SPAK kinases.

5.2. Modulation of chloride homeostasis via cation–chloride cotransporters

Emerging evidence suggests that chloride homeostasis is a therapeutic target for HD. Pharmacological agents that target cation–chloride cotransporters (i.e.NKCC1 orKCC2) therefore might be used to treat HD (figure 3b). Of note, dysregulation of cation–chloride cotransporters and GABA polarity was associated with several neuropsychiatric disorders [70,134–139] (reviewed in [27,140]). Such abnormal   receptor neurotransmission can be rescued by bumetanide, an NKCC1 inhibitor that decreases intracellular chloride concentration. Bumetanide is an FDA-approved diuretic agent that has been used in the clinic. It attenuates many neurological and psychiatric disorders in preclinical studies and some clinical trials for traumatic brain injury, seizure, chronic pain, cerebral infarction, Down syndrome, schizophrenia, fragile X syndrome and autism (reviewed in [141]). Daily intraperitoneal injections of bumetanide also restored the impaired motor function ofHDmice (R6/2, Y-T Hsu,Y-GChang, Y-CLi, K-YWang, H-MChen, D-J Lee, C-HTsai, C-C Lien,YChern 2018, personal communication). The effect of bumetanide is likely to be mediated by NKCC1 because genetic ablation of NKCC1 in the striatum also rescued the motor deficits in R6/2 mice (Y-T Hsu, Y-G Chang, Y-C Li, K-Y Wang, H-M Chen, D-J Lee, C-H Tsai, C-C Lien, Y Chern 2018, personal communication). This study uncovered a previously unrecognized depolarizing or excitatory action of GABA in the aberrant motor control in HD. In addition, chronic treatment with bumetanide also improved the impaired memory in R6/2 mice [69], supporting the importance of NKCC1 in HD pathogenesis. Owing to the poor ability of bumetanide to pass through the blood–brain barrier, further optimization of bumetanide and other NKCC1 inhibitors is warranted [142,143].

Disruption of KCC2 function is detrimental to inhibitory transmission and agents to activate KCC2 function would be beneficial in HD. However, no agonist of KCC2 has been described until very recently [144,145]. A new KCC2 agonist (CLP290) has been shown to facilitate functional recovery after spinal cord injury [145]. It would be of great interest to evaluate the effect of KCC2 agonists on HD progression. Another KCC2 activator, CLP257, was found to increase the cell surface expression of KCC2 in a rat model of neuropathic pain [146]. Post-translational modification of KCC2 by kinases may modulate the function of KCC2. The WNK/SPAK kinase complex, composed of WNK (with no lysine) and SPAK (SPS1-related proline/alanine-rich kinase), is known to phosphorylate and stimulate NKCC1 or inhibit KCC2 [147]. Thus, compounds that inhibit WNK/SPAK kinases will result in KCC2 activation and NKCC1 inhibition.

Some compounds have been noted as potential inhibitors of WNK/SPAK kinases and need to be further tested for their effects on cation–chloride cotransporters [148–150]. An alternative mechanism to activate KCC2 is manipulation of its interacting proteins (e.g. CKB [65,66]). Because CKB could activate the function of KCC2 [65,66], CKB enhancers may increase the function of KCC2. In HD, reduced expression and activity of CKB is associated with motor deficits and hearing impairment [68,88]. Enhancing CKB activity by creatine supplements ameliorated the motor deficits and hearing impairment of HD mice. It is worthwhile to further investigate the interaction of KCC2 and CKB in GABAergic neurotransmission and motor deficits in HD. The depolarizing GABA action with altered expression levels of NKCC1 or KCC2 is associated with neuroinflammation in HD brains [32,69]. Blockade of TNF-a using Xpro1595 (a dominant negative inhibitor of soluble TNF-a) [151] in vivo led to significant beneficial effects on disease progression in HD mice [152] and reduced the expression of NKCC1It would be of great interest to test the effect of other anti-inflammatory agents [153] on the function and expression of NKCC1 and GABAergic inhibition. Neuroinflammation is implicated in most neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer’s disease and Parkinson’s disease [154,155], and the interaction of cation–chloride cotransporters and neuroinflammation in GABAergic neurotransmission may also play a critical role in other neurodegenerative diseases.

Chloride extrusion enhancers as novel therapeutics for neurological diseases

Discovery of Novel SPAK Inhibitors That Block WNK Kinase Signaling to Cation Chloride Transporters

Upon activation by with-no-lysine kinases, STE20/SPS1-related proline–alanine-rich protein kinase (SPAK) phosphorylates and activates SLC12A transporters such as the Na⁺-Cl⁻ cotransporter (NCC) and Na⁺-K⁺-2Cl⁻ cotransporter type 1 (NKCC1) and type 2 (NKCC2); these transporters have important roles in regulating BP through NaCl reabsorption and vasoconstriction. SPAK knockout mice are viable and display hypotension with decreased activity (phosphorylation) of NCC and NKCC1 in the kidneys and aorta, respectively. Therefore, agents that inhibit SPAK activity could be a new class of antihypertensive drugs with dual actions (i.e., NaCl diuresis and vasodilation). In this study, we developed a new ELISA-based screening system to find novel SPAK inhibitors and screened >20,000 small-molecule compounds. Furthermore, we used a drug repositioning strategy to identify existing drugs that inhibit SPAK activity. As a result, we discovered one small-molecule compound (Stock 1S-14279) and an antiparasitic agent (Closantel) that inhibited SPAK-regulated phosphorylation and activation of NCC and NKCC1 in vitro and in mice. Notably, these compounds had structural similarity and inhibited SPAK in an ATP-insensitive manner. We propose that the two compounds found in this study may have great potential as novel antihypertensive drugs.

Chemical library screening for WNK signalling inhibitors using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy.

WNKs (with-no-lysine kinases) are the causative genes of a hereditary hypertensive disease, PHAII (pseudohypoaldosteronism type II), and form a signal cascade with OSR1 (oxidative stress-responsive 1)/SPAK (STE20/SPS1-related proline/alanine-rich protein kinase) and Slc12a (solute carrier family 12) transporters. We have shown that this signal cascade regulates blood pressure by controlling vascular tone as well as renal NaCl excretion. Therefore agents that inhibit this signal cascade could be a new class of antihypertensive drugs. Since the binding of WNK to OSR1/SPAK kinases was postulated to be important for signal transduction, we sought to discover inhibitors of WNK/SPAK binding by screening chemical compounds that disrupt the binding. For this purpose, we developed a high-throughput screening method using fluorescent correlation spectroscopy. As a result of screening 17000 compounds, we discovered two novel compounds that reproducibly disrupted the binding of WNK to SPAK. Both compounds mediated dose-dependent inhibition of hypotonicity-induced activation of WNK, namely the phosphorylation of SPAK and its downstream transporters NKCC1 (Na/K/Cl cotransporter 1) and NCC (NaCl cotransporter) in cultured cell lines. The two compounds could be the promising seeds of new types of antihypertensive drugs, and the method that we developed could be applied as a general screening method to identify compounds that disrupt the binding of two molecules.

N-Ethylmaleimide increases KCC2 cotransporter activity by modulating transporter phosphorylation

K⁺/Cl⁻ cotransporter 2 (KCC2) is selectively expressed in the adult nervous system and allows neurons to maintain low intracellular Cl⁻ levels. Thus, KCC2 activity is an essential prerequisite for fast hyperpolarizing synaptic inhibition mediated by type A γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA_A) receptors, which are Cl⁻-permeable, ligand-gated ion channels. Consistent with this, deficits in the activity of KCC2 lead to epilepsy and are also implicated in neurodevelopmental disorders, neuropathic pain, and schizophrenia. Accordingly, there is significant interest in developing activators of KCC2 as therapeutic agents. To provide insights into the cellular processes that determine KCC2 activity, we have investigated the mechanism by which N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) enhances transporter activity using a combination of biochemical and electrophysiological approaches. Our results revealed that, within 15 min, NEM increased cell surface levels of KCC2 and modulated the phosphorylation of key regulatory residues within the large cytoplasmic domain of KCC2 in neurons. More specifically, NEM increased the phosphorylation of serine 940 (Ser-940), whereas it decreased phosphorylation of threonine 1007 (Thr-1007). NEM also reduced with no lysine (WNK) kinase phosphorylation of Ste20-related proline/alanine-rich kinase (SPAK), a kinase that directly phosphorylates KCC2 at residue Thr-1007. Mutational analysis revealed that Thr-1007 dephosphorylation mediated the effects of NEM on KCC2 activity. Collectively, our results suggest that compounds that either increase the surface stability of KCC2 or reduce Thr-1007 phosphorylation may be of use as enhancers of KCC2 activity.

                                                                  

Tiagabine (trade name Gabitril) is n anticonvulsant medication produced by Cephalon that is used in the treatment of epilepsy. The drug is also used off-label in the treatment of anxiety disorders and panic disorder.

Tiagabine is approved by U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as an adjunctive treatment for partial seizures in individuals of age 12 and up. It may also be prescribed off-label by physicians to treat anxiety disorders and panic disorder as well as neuropathic pain (including fibromyalgia). For anxiety and neuropathic pain, tiagabine is used primarily to augment other treatments. Tiagabine may be used alongside selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, or benzodiazepines for anxiety, or antidepressants, gabapentin, other anticonvulsants, or opioids for neuropathic pain.^[4]

Tiagabine increases the level of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA), the major inhibitory neurotransmitter in the central nervous system, by blocking the GABA transporter 1 (GAT-1), and hence is classified as a GABA reuptake inhibitor (GRI).

Conclusion

Today’s post shows how you need to read well beyond the autism research, not to miss something useful.

Some of today’s suggested therapies for Huntington’s are likely to help some types of autism, but some will certainly have a negative effect in some people.  For example, increasing the amount of GABA in the CNS would do my son no good at all.

The emerging field of drugs that enhance KCC2 should be very beneficial to all those with autism who are bumetanide responders.

Enhancing CKB with creatine is interesting. Creatine is a muscle building supplement used by body builders and some DAN doctors. It does have interactions at high doses.