I did think of highlighting this
post to the Bumetanide researchers in France, but I do not think they would
take it seriously.
Another one to mention would be
this new study, funded by Rodakis, to look at why some antibiotics improve some
autism. Dr Luna at Baylor
College is running the study. Its basic
assumption is that the effect must be to do with bacteria, but as our reader Agnieszka
has highlighted, common penicillin type antibiotics increase expression of the
gene GLT-1 which then reduces glutamate in the brain. It has nothing to do with bacteria. Maybe for other antibiotics the effect does
relate to bacteria.
But if you
tell Dr Luna about GLT-1, quite likely she will not be interested.
Researchers will compare the gut
microbiome (bacteria, yeasts and fungi found in the gut) and metabolome (small
biological molecules produced by the microbes) of those who experience a change
in symptoms during antibiotic use to those who do not. The study may provide
valuable insight into when and why these changes occur and how this information
can be harnessed for future interventions.
There is even a case study very well documented here:-
Petra, our regular reader from Greece, has pointed out that Bumetanide has a greater effect in her adult son, with Asperger’s, when taken with Greek coffee and suggested why this might be.
Beta-Lactam Antibiotics as A Possible Novel Therapy for Managing Epilepsy and Autism, A Case Report and Review of Literature
Petra, our regular reader from Greece, has pointed out that Bumetanide has a greater effect in her adult son, with Asperger’s, when taken with Greek coffee and suggested why this might be.
Her reference is this article:-
It shows that the diuretic effect of low dose furosemide, with
dopamine, is greater than the effect of high dose furosemide.
The diuretic effect of Furosemide is via the transporter NKCC2,
which is the same affected by Bumetanide.
NKCC2 is found in your kidneys, while the very similar NKCC1 is
found in your brain. Furosemide and
Bumetanide affect both NKCC1 and NKCC2.
The caffeine in coffee is known to indirectly produce dopamine in
your body.
Greek coffee is nothing like your instant coffee or watery
Starbucks coffee, it contains a serious amount of caffeine.
The question is how does dopamine interact with
furosemide/bumetanide and will the effect in the kidney (NKCC2) also affect the
brain (NKCC1).
By more effectively blocking NKCC1 in neurons you would further
lower chloride levels and potentially further improve cognitive functioning.
This would further validate Petra’s observation.
Then we would consider if there is an alternative to Greek coffee,
or just accept that caffeine is the simplest and safest method to enhance
Bumetanide.
In the then end my conclusion is that coffee, or just the caffeine,
is a better option than a selective Dopamine D2 receptor agonist. But there is an interesting drug called
Bromocriptine that may be better in some cases.
Not only is it a dopamine D2 receptor agonist, but Bromocriptine also
“inhibits the release of glutamate, by reversing the GLT-1 (EAAT2) transporter”.
We came across the GLT-1 (EAAT2) transporter when we found why
some people with autism improve when on beta-lactam antibiotics (that include
the penicillin ones).
GLT-1/ EAAT2 is the principal transporter
that clears the excitatory neurotransmitter
glutamate from the extracellular space at synapses in the central
nervous system. Glutamate clearance is necessary for proper synaptic activation
and to prevent neuronal damage from excessive activation of glutamate
receptors. EAAT2 is responsible for over 90% of
glutamate reuptake within the brain
We saw that the drug riluzole approved for the treatment of ALS (Amyotrophic
Lateral Sclerosis) upregulates
EAAT2/GLT-1.
I suggested that people with autism who
improve on penicillin types antibiotics should get a similar effect from
riluzole. But riluzole is one of those
monstrously expensive drugs.
Based on my logic, we would then think that bromocriptine should
help treat ALS (Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis).
What did I find when I looked it up:-
Bromocriptine Mesylate Attenuates Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis: A
Phase 2a, Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Research in Japanese
Patients.
So then how much does Bromocriptine cost? It is a cheap generic. So a cost effective potential drug for ALS.
Bromocriptine has two potentially useful functions (Dopamine D2
and GLT-1),but it has numerous other effects:-
Bromocriptine blocks the release
of a hormone called prolactin, but this
should not be an issue for males.
Risperidone, one of only two
drugs approved for side effects of autism, can boost levels of prolactin.
Elevated prolactin levels are linked to a range of side effects,
including gynecomastia, or growth of breasts, in men and boys. This did not stop the drug being approved.
Bromocriptine agonizes the following monoamine receptors
- Dopamine D1 family
- Dopamine D2 family
- Serotonin 5-HT
- 5-HT1A (Ki=12.9 nM)
- 5-HT1B (Ki=355 nM)
- 5-HT1D (Ki=10.7 nM)
- 5-HT2A (Ki=107 nM)
- 5-HT2B (Ki=56.2 nM)
- 5-HT2C (Ki=741 nM)
- 5-HT6 (Ki=33 nM)
- Adrenergic α family
- α1A (Ki=4.17 nM)
- α1B (Ki=1.38 nM)
- α1D (Ki=1.12 nM)
- α2A (Ki=11.0 nM)
- α2B (Ki=34.7 nM)
- α2C (Ki=28.2 nM)
- Adrenergic β family
This is why drugs have side
effects.
But for people with ALS who cannot afford riluzole, the cheap generic bromocriptine might be a good
choice.
How about bromocriptine for autism?
Well there was a trial in Italy a long time ago on girls with Rett
syndrome
Twelve typical cases of the Rett syndrome and one forme
fruste were treated with bromocriptine for six months and then had a washout
for two months followed by resumption of the bromocriptine treatment. During the first bromocriptine
treatment there were improvements in communication and relaxation in some of
the girls: a more regular sleep pattern was observed in 4 and a more varied
facial expression in 8, and 4 girls began to utter a few words. The
bouts of hyperpnea disappeared in 5 and grinding of the teeth in 3. There was
also a reduction in stereotypic hand activities in 5 girls and signs of
improved motor abilities in 3. The washout caused a general decrease in the positive effects of the
previously administered bromocriptine and resumption of the treatment with this
drug led to less marked improvement. Metoclopramide was tested in all
the girls before the treatment, and it was noted that, while endorphins were
hyporesponsive, prolactin was hyperresponsive. This test was repeated two
months after the bromocriptine treatment had been performed and, while
beta-lipotropin remained unchanged, beta-endorphin showed increased
responsiveness.
Current
use of Dopamine with Lower Dose Diuretics
There is extensive knowledge of the effect of taking dopamine with
a bumetanide type diuretic.
Bumetanide by itself has a plateau above which a higher dose
causes no further diuresis, but when combined with dopamine there is more diuresis. Alternatively you can use a lower dose of bumetanide
and get the same amount of diuresis by adding dopamine.
Of interest to people with autism, it is found that you can reduce
the amount of potassium lost for the same amount of diuresis.
The effects of a
combination of dopamine and bumetanide were studied in eight patients with
oliguria not responsive to conventional treatment. Dopamine was infused at a
rate of 3 чg/kg/min and bumetanide was given as a 0.05-0.1 mg/kg bolus every 2
hours intravenously. Administration continued for 3 to 15 days. Urine output,
blood urea nitrogen, serum creatinine, the ratio of urine to plasma osmolarity,
free water clearance, and serum electrolytes were measured before, during, and
after the administration period. Six of the eight patients responded with an
increase in urine output and improvement of the other variables ; the other two
did not. We conclude that the combination of dopamine and high-dose bumetanide is effective in
increasing diuresis in critically ill patients in the early stages of
oliguria
How
does dopamine interact with NKCC1/2?
This is a very logical question, but there is something in the
literature on this subject. It does come
from frogs, but it was all I could find.
The different murine
D2-type dopamine receptors (D2L, D2S, D3L, D3S,
and D4) were expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes. The D2-type receptors
were all similarly and efficiently expressed in Xenopus oocytes and were shown to
bind the D2 antagonist [125I]sulpride. They were all shown to activate Cl− influx
upon agonist stimulation. Using the diagnostic inhibitor bumetanide, we
were able to separate the Na+/K+/2Cl−
cotransporter component of the Cl− influx from the total
unidirectional Cl− influx. The D3L
subtype was found to operate exclusively through the bumetanide-insensitive Cl−
influx whereas the other D2-type receptors acted on the Na+/K+/2Cl−
cotransporter as well. The pertussis toxin sensitivity of the
receptor-activated chloride influx via the Na+/K+/2Cl−
cotransporter varied between the various D2-type receptors showing that they
may couple to different G proteins, and activate different second messenger
systems.
In contrast to the
D2 and D3 receptor subtypes, D4 receptor activity was not significantly altered
by the presence of PTX, suggesting that in Xenopus oocytes it may couple with
one or more PTX-insensitive G proteins to cause changes in Cl3 influx. By
contrast, in the case of the D2 receptor, PTX reduced the total Cl3 influx
mediated by the D2S isoform by approximately 67%, and that mediated by the D2L
isoform by approximately 40% (Fig. 2A). However, the activities of the two
components of this ion influx, namely the bumetanide sensitive Na/K/2Cl-
cotransporter and the bumetanide-insensitive Cl- influx, differed between these
two isoforms. While the bumetanide-insensitive Cl3 influx was reduced by
approximately 60% by PTX for the D2L isoform, it was only slightly reduced for
the D2S isoform (Fig. 2C). Thus, the majority of the inhibitory effect of PTX
on the D2S-induced influx was caused by uncoupling from the signalling cascade
that activates the Na/K/2Cl- cotransporter. On the other hand, the signal
transduction pathway that activates the cotransporter after stimulation of the
D2L receptor remained relatively unaffected by PTX (Fig. 2B), indicating that
D2S and D2L couple to different G proteins when expressed in Xenopus oocytes.
For the D3 receptor, both long and short isoforms showed a reduction (50^60%)
in the presence of PTX, at the bumetanide-insensitive Cl- influx (Fig. 2C),
whereas for both D3 receptor isoforms, PTX had little or no effect on the Na/K/2Cl-
cotransporter, indicated by the bumetanide-sensitive component of the Cl3
influx (Fig. 2B).
PTX = pertussis
toxin
Caffeine among its many effects is effectively a dopamine D2/3
receptor agonist.
Conclusion
As I understand from the large scale trial use of bumetanide use
in autism, there is indeed an issue with hypokalemia (loss of potassium).
I would think that this should be solvable using a supplement and
dietary potassium. Agnieszka pointed out
that kiwis have the advantage of potassium with little carbohydrate, as do
avocados. Bananas and orange juice are the traditional potassium-rich foods for
people on diuretics.
This is a case where the care giver has to play an active role, it
is not just about the doctor prescribing a pill. The care giver has to manage the process to
minimize the side effects. So potassium
needs to be managed, as does fluid intake.
For people who struggle with hypokalemia, the idea of a lower dose
of bumetanide, but with dopamine, could be interesting. The other method is to add a potassium
sparing diuretic like spironolactone.
For my son, the dietary option, plus 250mg of potassium twice a
day, is very effective. Now I just have
to persuade him to take a Greek coffee with his breakfast.
For people whose autism responds to penicillin type antibiotics
and who take bumetanide then Bromocriptine might be interesting as a caffeine alternative.